GeoCitiesRank My SiteTake A TourMy GuestbookChat
Pages Like MineSearchSend This PageForums
Email Me
Athens
Click Here!
Click Here!

libertarian Unschooling | Kid's Gaming

Dinosaurs vs. Ropods

or When are we supposed to teach our children that when adults ask them questions, they don't really want to know the answers?

By N. S. GILL

Copyright 1993 N.S. Gill

My decision to homeschool started when I was pregnant, as an inspired response to the question, "where will you send your child to school?" and grew as I saw the problems of the public schools repeated in the private ones, as I read the available homeschooling literature, and as I argued with friends about homeschooling.
space The few dealings my son and I have had with the public school have only served to increase my fervor. However, for the first five years of my son's life, the only people I knew who were homeschooling were one neighbor and the couple whom I had talked into doing the same with their children, and the family that they, in turn, had persuaded to homeschool.
spaceWhen my son turned three he had his preschool screening. Today I am apologetic about having allowed my son to undergo this outrage, but then I wasn't even conscious of what an imposition this was. All the ramifications of homeschooling had not yet crystallized in my minds. The pre-school screening, however, turned out to be one of the major pieces of ammunition I had in the fight against friends and family who opposed homeschooling.
spaceMy son's score was somewhat better than his age suggested, but not as high as it would have been had the test had any relevance to his life--instead of being a test of how well he had been inculturated. Did he know how to do all the things that children in proper daycare do? No. He had been at home with me all the time. Would he follow a strange woman's instructions and give the right answer? No. He didn't like the test administrator or her meaningless test.
spaceAnswering depended on his mood. The woman asked him to identify certain colors. Colorblind, my son failed that part of the test. Since he had never enjoyed playing with blocks, he was unable to rearrange the blocks as rapidly as she wanted. Next, she asked him to write some letters; then she counted the strokes. No matter that my son's E didn't look like an E, it took four strokes and was ipso facto, right. No matter that his A was made using an L upside down all in one stroke, almost attached to an upright leg and a horizontal bar. It took three strokes and was, therefore, correct. He got in trouble, though, for his F that took four strokes (she'd probably have penalized medieval scribes who used two strokes to round a C) and for his inability to pronounce the letter correctly. (Actually, I got in trouble for that one because I wasn't worried.)
spaceHe could not hop on one foot (my fault, of course, since I had failed to train him in this part of his required orderly progression of developmental skills) although he liked that part of the test and would have kept trying until he had succeeded if she'd have let him, but she had other tasks for him.
spaceHe was to determine which of two very obvious items was bigger. He answered several of these inane comparisons without hesitation, but then grew bored. So, when she asked him which was bigger, a mouse or a dog, my son answered using his hands to show relative size, "A mouse is this big, a dog is this big, but a dinosaur is REALLY big." He wanted to give this apparently very stupid woman some real help. She repeated her question a couple of times, and my son repeated his answer. He refused to answer any further questions.
spaceAs I said, I regret having put my son through this test, although it did prepare him for the same sort of test at the doctor's office, and it made me aware of what aspects of intellectual development were fostered by the establishment. Obviously helpfulness and original thinking were not. My friends agreed with me that if that's the way accomplishment and maturity are gauged by the schools, that my son would do miserably in them. One friend, a former teacher, ordered the Hegeners' The Home School Reader for me. Another friend, a welfare worker, became an informal advocate for homeschooling.
spaceThis is the first year I will have to give my son (now seven) the schools' achievement test. I am almost certain that it will be just as irrelevant and difficult for him to answer as the first--not because he's stupid or ignorant. How can he be when he learns arithmetic by beating me daily in Cribbage and social studies by discussing the Rush Limbaugh Program?

Originally printed in The Grapevine (1993)

Copyright 1996 & 1997 N. S. Gill.
This page hosted by GeoCities. Get Your Free Home page.